Best Pizza
Neapolitan ovens, New York slices and neighborhood favorites across Brevard.
About the photos: Photos in this section are AI-generated illustrations, not real photos from these restaurants.
Florida Today counts more than 100 pizza joints in Brevard, and the best of them would hold their own anywhere, from Naples-trained wood-fired pies to 24-inch New York slices and square grandma-style pans. Here are our picks, a mix of highly rated favorites, local institutions and a couple of newcomers that opened in 2025, spread from Titusville to Palm Bay. Prices and pies come from each spot's own menu or the source linked, so check before you go.
Our picks: editorial choices by The Space Coast Wire, not ratings from any review site.
AI-generated image. Illustration based on the menu description, not an actual photo of this dish. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Editor's pick
🍕 Star Luca: a star-shaped pie with ricotta-filled points, Italian tomato sauce, mozzarella, spicy salami calabrese and basil
Our editor's favorite, and the numbers back it up: ultra-thin pies built on dough that ferments 72 to 96 hours, playful star-shaped specialty pizzas, and the No. 1 pizza spot in Melbourne on Tripadvisor (4.9 of 5, 458 reviews as shown). Florida Today named it to its 2026 list of Brevard's best pizza. (Mister O1 Melbourne: location & hours, Mister O1 Melbourne menu (PDF), Florida Today: Best pizza in Brevard County, 20 local favorites (Aug 2026, paywalled), Tripadvisor: best pizza in Melbourne (2026))
AI-generated image. Illustration based on the menu description, not an actual photo of this dish. Mangia & Bevi Pizzeria Napoletana
🍕 Nduja: spicy Calabrian salami on a Margherita base, topped with fresh burrata (12-inch); the classic Margherita is listed at $13
True Naples-style pies with airy wood-fired crusts, plus Neapolitan favorites you rarely see locally, like salsiccia e friarielli (sausage and broccoli rabe) and a mortadella-and-pistachio white pie. Florida Today included it among Brevard's 20 best pizza spots in 2026. (Mangia & Bevi Pizzeria Napoletana: menu & ordering, Florida Today: Best pizza in Brevard County (Aug 2026, paywalled))
AI-generated image. Illustration based on the menu description, not an actual photo of this dish. Botta Neapolitan Pizzeria & Bakery NEW · Opened January 11, 2025
🍕 Mortadella Burrata: San Marzano DOP sauce, mozzarella, mortadella with pistachios, arugula, burrata, herb oil and pistachio crumble
Opened in January 2025 by AVPN-trained pizzaiolo Enrico Botta, who studied in Naples and imports his flour and tomatoes. It offers two crusts, soft Neapolitan and crispy Pinsa Romana, plus a bakery bar of cannoli and gelato. Florida Today put it on its 2026 best-pizza list. (Botta Neapolitan: menu, hours & location, Viera Voice: Heritage, special training, experience create authentic pizza (Feb 2025), Florida Today: Best pizza in Brevard County (Aug 2026, paywalled))
AI-generated image. Illustration based on the menu description, not an actual photo of this dish. FM Pizza Oven
🍕 The Cuban ($24): mustard-mayo base, mozzarella and Swiss, pulled pork, smoked ham and pickles; also the Brussels Sprout pie ($22)
The most inventive menu on our list, served inside a converted bank building in EGAD: a Cuban-sandwich pizza, a Thai chicken pie, wood-fired pizza pot pies, vegan toppings and local Intracoastal beers on tap. (FM Pizza Oven: menu, Florida Today: Best pizza in Brevard County (Aug 2026, paywalled))
AI-generated image. Illustration based on the menu description, not an actual photo of this dish. Genna Pizza Company
🍕 Coal-fired The Godfather: Brooklyn mozzarella, soppressata picante, Chicago sausage, Italian cherry peppers and pecorino romano
One kitchen, many styles: coal-fired, New York, Detroit square pans, Chicago deep-dish and wood-fired, with a New England white clam pie on the coal-fired menu. Readers pushed it into Florida Today's 2024 pizza bracket with an overwhelming response, and it made the paper's 2026 best-pizza list. (Genna Pizza: coal-fired pizzas & hours, Florida Today: Best pizza in Brevard County (Aug 2026, paywalled), Florida Today: Best pizza in Brevard? March Madness pizza edition (Mar 2024, paywalled))
AI-generated image. Illustration based on the menu description, not an actual photo of this dish. The GOAT NEW · Opened August 2025
🍕 The Nonna: square pan-style cheese pizza with fresh basil and Romano ($6 a slice)
North Brevard's newest pizza hit, baking square, focaccia-like grandma-style pies since August 2025 with house-made dough and sub rolls. Florida Today's January 2026 roundup of under-the-radar restaurants said it quickly became a community favorite. (The GOAT Titusville, The GOAT: menu, Florida Today: 10 restaurants that fly under the radar (Jan 2026, paywalled))
AI-generated image. Illustration based on the menu description, not an actual photo of this dish. Pappagallo's Pizza👀 Water view
🍕 Hand-tossed Deluxe (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, peppers, olives, onions, extra cheese), or the Angry Meatball as a calzone or stromboli
A beachside fan favorite on A1A with homemade dough and sauce, rated 4.8 of 5 across 3,292 reviews as shown on DiscoverHappyHours. Florida Today's 2026 list noted its ocean view. (Pappagallo's Pizza, DiscoverHappyHours: Pappagallo's menu & ratings (updated Aug 2026), Florida Today: Best pizza in Brevard County (Aug 2026, paywalled))
AI-generated image. Illustration based on the menu description, not an actual photo of this dish. Ryan's Pizza & Pub
🍕 Ryan's Special (16-inch $29, 18-inch $33, 24-inch $40): pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, beef, onions, peppers, mushrooms and olives
A two-story Irish pizzeria facing Riverfront Park and the Indian River in Historic Cocoa Village, with 14 draft beers, live local bands and Irish nachos. It's a crowd-pleaser before a show at the Cocoa Village Playhouse, rated 4.4 of 5 across 3,447 reviews as shown on DiscoverHappyHours. (Visit Space Coast: Ryan's Pizza & Pub, DiscoverHappyHours: Ryan's menu & ratings (updated Aug 2026), Ryan's Pizza and Pub)
AI-generated image. Illustration based on the menu description, not an actual photo of this dish. Humpavelli's Pizza
🍕 The Pickle Pizza ($19 / $23 / $30): olive oil and garlic base, dill pickles, extra mozzarella; or go big with the 24-inch house pie
The family-owned home of the 24-inch pizza, open since 2013, with everything made in-house every morning. It even takes on-base orders for Kennedy Space Center, and its own site touts being voted Brevard's best pizza in 2019 and 2024. (Humpavelli's Pizza: menu, Humpavelli's Pizza, Florida Today: Best pizza in Brevard County (Aug 2026, paywalled))
AI-generated image. Illustration based on the menu description, not an actual photo of this dish. Bizzarro Pizza
🍕 Bizzarro Supreme (medium $22.99, large $25.99): pepperoni, sausage, beef, ham, mushrooms, peppers, onions, olives and extra mozzarella
Palm Bay's pick for oversized New York slices on a thin crust, plus stuffed pizzas and strombolis. Florida Today's 2026 list called it widely praised, and its walk-in lunch special gets you two cheese slices and a soda for $8. (Bizzarro Pizza Palm Bay Road: menu, Florida Today: Best pizza in Brevard County (Aug 2026, paywalled))
Keep Exploring
Breweries10 placesExplore →Brevard Top 1010 placesExplore →New & Coming Soon95 placesExplore →Waterfront7 placesExplore →Surprise MeJump somewhere randomRoll →